Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street
30 01 2008
I was probably about four years old when my grandfather first told me the legend of Sweeney Todd, the crazed barber who slit his patrons’ throats before having their flesh baked into delicious meat pies. The tale, while more than likely apocryphal, touches on several fears close to most people’s hearts, not the least of which is unwittingly eating a fellow human being (and worse still, actually enjoying it).
Todd’s story was adapted countless times over the last couple of centuries, but the most notable in recent times was the 1979 Broadway musical by Stephen Sondheim and Hugh Wheeler, itself based on a 1973 play by Christopher Bond. The play and musical added greater depth to the story by transforming it into a macabre tale of tragedy and revenge, and now director Tim Burton has adapted the musical into a Hollywood film.
Sweeney Todd (Burton-favourite Johnny Depp) was once Benjamin Barker, a meek and mild barber living in London with a beautiful wife and child. But when the slimy Judge Turpin (Alan Rickman) coverts Barker’s wife, he frames the barber and has him transported to Australia; now, 15 years later, Barker returns to London as Todd, a man devoured by thoughts of revenge.
Alas, once in London, Todd learns from his landlady Mrs. Lovett (Helena Bonham Carter) that his wife poisoned herself, and from there he loses his last shred of humanity. His planned revenge on the Judge, once frustrated, transforms into revenge upon society as a whole, and his killing spree results in the perfect ingredient for Lovett’s hitherto inedible meat pies.

Once again, Burton’s involvement is self-evident: his Gothic sensibilities fit perfectly with this Dickensian London that seems to exist in the bowels of hell. If there’s a contemporary musical that Burton was born to adapt to the screen, it’s this. Unfortunately, Burton’s sense of whimsy and playfulness is (for the most part) sorely missed here. The one sequence that allows him a chance to inject the lighter part of his personality into the proceedings is “By the Sea” — a much-needed moment of respite from the grim goings-on throughout the rest of the film — but for the bulk of the running time, we’re treated to angst punctuated by copious blood-letting.
Furthermore, things really slow to a crawl during the romantic subplot between Anthony (Jamie Campbell Bower) and Johanna (Jayne Wisener), which only has a tangential connection to the main story and isn’t engaging in the slightest. On the other hand, Sacha Baron Cohen is delightful as the rival barber Pirelli, but, of course, his part is short-lived (no pun intended).
The curious thing about Sweeney Todd is that, for a mainstream film, the audience seems quite limited. There’s far too much blood for your average musical fan, yet far too much singing for most filmgoers willing to put up with the gore. And I must emphasise that there’s a lot of singing — hardly any dialogue is actually spoken — and the melodies aren’t particularly memorable, either. I know I’m sounding like an uneducated philistine here, but ultimately there seemed to be a lot to admire about the film but little to actually like about it. This may be one of Burton’s most accomplished films, but it’s also one of his most emotionally distant. I’ll take Ed Wood or even Sleepy Hollow over this any day of the week.
Put simply, this is Burton at his darkest and most gruesome. The craft on display is impeccable, but the film itself feels cold, keeping the audience at arm’s length. Perhaps, like Todd’s own victims, his story has been recycled for consumption that many times that the servings may seem more appetising than they really are.





Comments : 2 Comments »
Tags : 2007, musical, horror, Johnny Depp, Helena Bonham Carter, Alan Rickman, Sacha Baron Cohen, Jamie Campbell Bower, Jayne Wisener, John Logan, Stephen Sondheim, Hugh Wheeler, Christopher Bond
Categories : At the flicks
In 1981, George Lucas and Steven Spielberg were two of the hottest names in town: Lucas had made American Graffiti, Star Wars and The Empire Strikes Back; Spielberg, meanwhile, had directed the blockbusters Jaws and Close Encounters of the Third Kind. A film produced by Lucas and directed by Spielberg would almost certainly be money in the bank.
The human condition spans continents, uniting us despite the gulfs created by distance, language and culture — this is the theme of Babel, the last film by director Alejandro González Iñárritu and writer Guillermo Arriaga. At least, that’s what I think the theme is, yet despite a nearly two-and-a-half hour running time, I’m still not quite sure.
1982 was a good year for science fiction on film: on the one hand you had Steven Speilberg’s E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial, which was one of those inescapable blockbusters that was as much an event as a film; on the other hand we were given John Carpenter’s The Thing, which seemed to be the cinematic inverse of Spielberg’s offering. Transcending that dichotomy, however, was Ridley Scott’s Blade Runner, a futuristic film noir that is arguably the most important science fiction film of the 1980s — certainly, it was one of the most influential.
Early in Ridley Scott’s American Gangster, Russell Crowe’s character, a New Jersey detective, discovers almost $1 million in unmarked bills in the trunk of a car. Does he take the money? If he does, he’s entering into the murky world of corruption that the bulk of his colleagues seem to inhabit; if he doesn’t, he’s putting himself in immediate danger because, as his partner observes, “Cops kill cops they can’t trust.” He decides to turn in the money anyway.
At their worst, romantic comedies display an utter contempt for their target demographic, assuming that any woman seeking out a rom-com isn’t particularly interested in genuine wit or insight — it’s essentially porn for the girly set. (A similar argument can be made for the action genre, mind you, with the genders switched.) 27 Dresses, while still following the conventions of genre, nonetheless never feels like it’s pandering or condescending to its audience.
Hilary Swank is a talented actress, winning an Oscar not only for her performance in Clint Eastwood’s Million Dollar Baby, but also as the transgendered Brandon Teena in Boys Don’t Cry. Why she’d choose to then star in such a tepid romance as P.S. I Love You is a mystery right up there with the meaning of Stonehenge and the reason why Travolta never made Battlefield Earth 2.
In late 1979, Pink Floyd released their double-LP concept-album The Wall, a satire and diatribe that savaged the rock ‘n’ roll lifestyle while including pot-shots aimed at a sadistic education system and the personal effects of war. This was bassist Roger Waters’ baby, being as he conceived of the project in isolation and wrote the bulk of the material on the album.
Quite a few films have a behind-the-scenes history of power struggles and “creative differences”, but only a select few enter lore as being films that almost devoured their creators. Apocalypse Now is one such film; Brazil is another.
Mike Nichols’ The Graduate was a great film — a classic, even — that was based on a novel by author Charles Webb. Hope Springs is also based on a novel by Webb, but don’t let that fool you into thinking this movie might be anything other than barely passable.
Recent Comments